Hellenic Society of Archaeometry  


Hellenic Society for Archaeometry
http://www.archaeometry.gr/eae/HSA.htm

Athens Greece, May 28-31 2003
National Hellenic Research Foundation
Lecture Hall "Leonidas Zervas"

Theme session:
"Archaeometry Studies in the Aegean: Reviews and recent developments"

Home Page Programme - Abstracts Information Accommodation Activities Links

WAS PLATO'S RITUAL CAPTURE OF BULLS AT ATLANTIS A RESULT OF HIS IMAGINATION, A PREHISTORIC MEMORY FROM THE AEGEAN, ANATOLIA, OR FROM AFRICA ?

  • St. P. Papamarinopoulos (Laboratory of Geophysics, Section of applied Geology and Geophysics, Department of Geology, University of Patras, 261 10 Patras, Greece)

In a particular passage of Plato's Critias a ritual scene of bulls was described by Plato. The participants kings of Atlantis attempt to capture ritually bulls without metal weapons but with staves and nooses. They further sacrifise the captured bull putting its head on an altar and cut its throat. The very vivid textual scene is compared with what was known to Plato in his century and in the 5th century B.C. in Greece and in its colonies. It is found not fitting with the known archaeological evidence. Then it is compared with scenes from prehistoric Peloponnese and Crete in which bulls are captured in the wild non-ritually. It is found not to fit as well. The famous leaping over the bull of the young acrobats is indeed without weapons but the staves and the nooses are missing both in prehistoric Cretan sites in the Aegean and in Africa The sce-ne further is compared with neolithic and prehistoric rites in Anatolia. Again not any similarity is found. However, taking into account the pyramidical texts an obvious similarity is illustrated with Ramses II. The pictorial evidence shows lassoing Ramses and a prince close by assisting him to perform a ritual capture of the Apis without weapons as Plato describes. The capture of the bull by common people in Egypt is also taken into account. It exhibits no similarity with the scene presented by Plato.The evidence pushes the position of Atlantis away from the Aegean to Africa. Initially in Egypt. The research will show where we go next.

Last update on May 16, 2003
SPONSORS
MINISTRY OF CULTURE * MINISTRY OF THE AEGEAN * NATIONAL HELLENIC RESEARCH FOUNDATION * TECHNICAL CHAMBER OF GREECE * AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES AT ATHENS * HOTEL HIPPOCAMPUS, NAOUSSA PAROS